You are browsing a read-only backup copy of Wikitech. The live site can be found at

Talk:Wikitech IDM: Difference between revisions

From Wikitech-static
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Slyngshede moved page Talk:Wikitech IDM to Talk:Wikimedia IDM)
Line 1: Line 1:
== Naming ==
#REDIRECT [[Talk:Wikimedia IDM]]
Could we name this project as something else than ''''Wikitech''' IDM', in line with the other work in the recent years to avoid using Wikitech naming for anything Developer account related? This is mostly to avoid confusion if/when Wikitech finally becomes a SUL wiki? [[User:Majavah|Majavah]] ([[User talk:Majavah|talk!]]) 11:42, 28 September 2022 (UTC)
:The accounts that it would be managing are canonically called [[mw:Developer account|developer accounts]]. I agree that having "wikitech" anywhere in the name of this non-wiki account management system will be confusing for everyone. -- [[User:BryanDavis|BryanDavis]] ([[User talk:BryanDavis|talk]]) 21:58, 28 September 2022 (UTC)
== Cloud VPS ssh key management use case missing from future plan ==
The [[Wikitech_IDM#Status_quo_2|Modifying account settings / Status quo]] section correctly identifies Cloud VPS SSH key management as a current use case. I do not see this listed as an editable attribute in the [[Wikitech_IDM#Future_2|Modifying account settings / Future]] list. Is this an oversight or has this use case been deliberately excluded from the planned application? [[User:BryanDavis|BryanDavis]] ([[User talk:BryanDavis|talk]]) 22:03, 28 September 2022 (UTC)
== Replacement for Wikitech as a source of 2FA protection for developer accounts ==
One use case that I see missing from set of major use cases is TOTP-based 2FA for developer accounts. This is currently provided by the combination of MediaWiki and the [ action=oathvalidate] API endpoint. Both Striker and Horizon use this API to enforce 2FA protection for developer account authentication today. -- [[User:BryanDavis|BryanDavis]] ([[User talk:BryanDavis|talk]]) 22:13, 28 September 2022 (UTC)
== Anti-spoofing, naming deny list, IP range blocking all provided "for free" by MediaWiki today ==
Something that is likely non-obvious when thinking about a system to replace MediaWiki for developer account creation is the number of "free" account related features that exist today on wikitech thanks to MediaWiki and integration with When I implemented developer account creation in [[Striker]], there were a few things that I discovered I needed to make API calls to wikitech for to keep feature parity:
IP range block checking via [ action=query&list=blocks] is used to provide a small degree of protection against known abusers. This check also includes global blocks which have been created by [[meta:Stewards|Stewards]].
User name allowed checking via [ action=query&list=users&usprop=cancreate]. This checks against the local [[MediaWiki:Titleblacklist]] which we mostly use reserve the names of various system level accounts. Additionally the cross-wiki [[meta:Title blacklist]] is checked. The API call also invokes the protections of [[mw:Extension:AntiSpoof]] which are largely unnecessary for shell account names due to their ascii charset restrictions, but which may be useful for ''cn'' or ''sn'' attributes depending on how they are expected to be used in the resulting dataset. For currently existing developer accounts both ''cn'' and ''sn'' (should) contain the same value which is also known as the developer account's "username". This attribute is commonly used by wikitech as the wiki account username as well as being used in Gerrit, Phabricator, Horizon, Striker, and some other LDAP backed authn as the account name for authentication.
It would be worth considering the continued use of these MediaWiki API checks rather than attempting to re-implement similar functionality in a stand alone system. The synergy effects with Steward actions on the content wikis are especially difficult to replicate independently. -- [[User:BryanDavis|BryanDavis]] ([[User talk:BryanDavis|talk]]) 23:00, 28 September 2022 (UTC)
== Remote API for account creation? ==
A use case I would like to propose is a proper API that would allow account creation from external apps. My specific use case is retaining account creation functionality in [[Striker]] so that we do not have a feature regression there which would complicate the new Toolforge user workflow. -- [[User:BryanDavis|BryanDavis]] ([[User talk:BryanDavis|talk]]) 23:11, 28 September 2022 (UTC)
== Reviewing Striker for things that may be worth stealing or extracting ==
Way back in the olden days of 2017 I had conversations with {{U|Faidon Liambotis|Faidon}}, {{U|Volans|Riccardo}}, {{U|Aklapper|Andre}}, and a few other folks about the need for this type of system. Some very rough and high level information from those discussions is captured in [[phab:T179463|T179463]]. Over the years we have touched base from time to time (usually during annual planning) to see if we had capacity to work on it yet. Seeing the announcement that this is finally happening on wikitech-l was a very nice thing. :)
One of the things mentioned in that phab task is that [[Striker]] already handles the account creation workflow and some bits of the account editing workflows. This code was not strictly written with reuse in mind, but I do think that there are things there which are at least worth being used as a reference when building this bigger and better identity management service. I would like to publicly offer to walk through the code of Striker and try to explain anything that seems weird to anyone who is interested. -- [[User:BryanDavis|BryanDavis]] ([[User talk:BryanDavis|talk]]) 23:30, 28 September 2022 (UTC)

Latest revision as of 10:44, 29 September 2022

Redirect to: